This past weekend, I got to playtest a new build of Girlframe by Isabelle Ruubsaat.
What a game. It was something that left me inspired and wanting to write my own games immediately after playing. Isabelle's design is thoughtful, electric, and so very unique amongst other games in the very-saturated PBTA design space.
Instead of doing a full mechanic-by-mechanic review, I want to zoom in on Girlframe's core mechanic, how it works, and what it's got me thinking about in terms of my own design.
Rolls, Plays, and Heat
In Girlframe, you play one of the eponymous Girls-- a (implied) young woman who has been taken, transformed, and reprogrammed into a footsoldier for the omnipresent Foundation to fight the cosmic, alien threat called Gorgons. It is a game that dives into common mechsploitation tropes like dehumanization and worker exploitation, and holds those tropes together with fresh questions about gender, relationships, sex, and power.
Most times when you make a play (called moves in many other Powered by the Apocalypse games), you'll need to make a roll. It works like this:
- Roll two six-sided dice, and add them together. Add your Heat to the result (we'll get into Heat below).
- On a 7 or lower total, it usually goes badly for you. On an 8-10, it will usually go well. On an 11 or higher, you overdo it-- get what you want (sort of) but with a punishing consequence that edges your action into a pyrrhic victory.
- After the roll is resolved, reduce your Heat by 1 and keep it moving.
Unlike most games in the space, Girlframe does not follow a 'number go up' philosophy. You're aiming for the middle. A Heat modifier of +2 or +3 is best, and anything lower or higher edges you into results that you don't want. You're an unstable, unwilling soldier in constant competition with your cadre, grappling with your own identity and individuality while you try to keep your head above water. This game isn't about getting the highest modifier possible-- you need to be in control. Precise. Focused.
Girlframe represents the inner turmoil, rage, and adrenaline of your Girl through Heat, a metaresource that you gain from two sources: Identities, and Tags. Identities are more permanent aspects of how your Girl views themselves, and Tags are temporary labels placed on you by other people. Over the course of a game, your Girl's Identities and Tags will shift: I started with the 'Pretty, Programmed, and Perfect' identities, and a 'Teetering on the Edge' Tag. After a scene where my Girl failed to keep her composure and lost it in front of another Girl, I chose to replace 'Programmed' with 'Teetering on the Edge', making the latter a core part of my Girl's ego. I later lost 'Teetering on the Edge' entirely after I regained control and fucked with another Girl's memories, asserting myself as top dog once more.
Before or after you make a roll, you can choose to mark Identities or Tags (you cannot mark Identities that have been marked already. You get chances to unmark them, but it's rare). Identities raise your Heat by +2, and Tags can raise (or lower) your Heat by 1. Heat remains in between rolls-- if you burn a bunch of Identities to get a bunch of Heat and pull something off, you risk vulnerability to that 11+ result on your next couple rolls in the future.
Let's look at a scenario:
- I roll a 3 on my 2d6 roll. I don't have any Heat.
- To get up to the 8-10 result I want, I mark two Identities and a Tag, bringing myself to 5 heat. I get that 8-10, and then reduce my Heat by 1, to 4.
- My next roll, I roll a 7 on the 2d6, and add my 2 Heat, bringing me to an 11+. I overdo it, and hurt my Girl.
This core mechanic does several things I really like:
- Shooting for a middle result does two things: it makes gameplay less about 'get the biggest number you can', and fulfills the fantasy of playing someone just barely keeping it together trying to remain focused.
- Heat is a terrific metaresource. It is transparent and easy to visualize, and like any good metaresource, it has a fictive counterpart. When my Girl is at 5 Heat, I know she's firing at all cylinders-- she's filled with adrenaline, or angry, or anxious, etc. If I succeed, it's because I kept that under control, and not because I'm operating healthily.
- Heat, Tags, and Identities shifting throughout play means every roll is different. Every time I act, I have to think about who my Girl is right now: Pretty and Perfect are marked, and Teetering on the Edge is not. The only resource I/she can draw upon is this crack in the shell-- this desperation to stay on top and retain her privileges as the Ace.
Electric mechanic. Let's talk about how it's inspired me for Inkwarren.
Inkwarren: Latest Thoughts
As I design Inkwarren's latest draft, I've been throwing a lot of stuff at the wall-- things I've wanted to try for a while that I haven't because I don't want to rock the system too much. Lately, I've turned my attention to the core mechanic: how can I reflect the tagline, 'Courage in a cruel world.' through the base elements of the system? How can I make woodlanders feel small alone, and strong together?
The current core mechanic is evocative of a lot of adventure games, and I'm not entirely sure I dislike it. Draw a card from the Minor Arcana, add a modifier. If it is 11+, you Prevail and get what you want. If it's 10-, you Falter: either accept the results and gain a resource called Courage, or spend Courage you already have to change your result to Persevere (a mixed success). If you draw a suit matching the attribute added to the draw, the result is True: it's more impactful on the fiction with greater effects or side effects. Prevails are impressive, and Falters are damning.
It works okay. Currently, woodlanders succeed a lot, and Falters are rare if they're smart with their resources. I want failure to be a bit more common, and drive home the 'imperfect results still move the story forward' vibe I'm imagining. The huge pain point has been the four Attributes: coming up with four Attributes that are freeform enough to reward creativity but strictive enough to not just be applicable to any scenario is really hard.
Naturally, after playing Girlframe, I was really inspired. One of my players has floated a 'no attributes' core mechanic for a while, and I've been resistant because I wanted to incorporate the suits of the deck into the draw itself. I loved the varying bonus of Heat, and the 'shoot for the middle' roll that the system builds itself around. Yesterday, at a coffee shop with my boyfriend, I sat down to sketch out an idea of how a similar idea might translate to the tarot deck.
Surprise, surprise: cards and dice are different! Drawing a single card from the Minor Arcana has a flat accuracy that varies and changes depending on how many 'successes' are still left in the deck. Your modifier can shift and vary the number of successes, but you'll never achieve the same odds as the bounded accuracy curve that Girlframe uses with its 2d6.
I went through a couple of different scenarios: what if we removed Court cards (currently all valued at 11) from the Minor Arcana, giving us a straight 1-10 value that we could use like a 2d10? Then we could have a curve that looks like: 1-10 fail, 11-15 succeed, 16+ overdo it (numbers are loosely interposed).
This didn't satisfy me. Part of it is that the numbers start to get bigger, and I like smaller numbers as a design and aesthetic choice for this game. The other part? I'm not using dice for a reason. Why am I trying to use dice?
Cards are wonderful for many reasons. They are intensely gameable, and results in the deck will shift and change based on what's already been drawn. Every time a woodlander draws a Court card or a 10, that's one less definite success left in the deck (until it's reshuffled). The cards have so many different variables that we can use to set up randomness in the game: the parity of the card value, the card value itself, the suit, or two suits, or grouping values by two. They give a defined 'vibe' to play that you would normally have to buy specialty or bespoke dice to evoke.
Inkwarren must be its own thing, however wonderful Girlframe is. I'd still like to use some things: I like the idea of shifting modifiers and not shooting for the highest result. The hurdle is matching it to what I want for my game: which is a wonderful aspect of game design in general.
Girlframe is a terrific game that everyone should play. Until next time!
No comments:
Post a Comment